Posts Tagged ‘Liberalism’s future’

More Like Grayson

Wednesday, November 4th, 2009

Representative Alan Grayson (D, FL) is getting some bad reviews from the mainstream press. But this is to be expected. The mainstream press hates anyone who disrupts their cozy narratives.

First it was his comment, “If you get sick, America, the Republicans’ health care plan is this: Die quickly.” Then, appearing on MSNBC, he said of former Vice President Dick Cheney: “I have trouble listening to what he says sometimes because of the blood that drips from his teeth while he’s talking.” Finally, a radio interview surfaced in which he had called a female adviser to the Federal Reserve chairman “a K Street whore” — a reference to her former job as a Washington lobbyist. That one forced him to make a formal apology.

But this is exactly the kind of rhetoric Democrats need.

The country is divided between two opposing ideologies with very little middle ground on which to construct bi-partisan compromise. The financial collapse, the plight of homeowners, the sluggish economy, and persistent high unemployment have everyone in the country in a foul mood and poised to throw-the-bums-out if things don’t turn around.

And the bums are Democrats since they are in power.

Being nice to the other side will produce few results and will make Democrats appear to lack commitment to their ideas.

The Republicans have their tired anti-government, anti-liberal rhetoric, which will appeal to many voters who are looking for easy answers and who quickly forget the role Republicans played in creating this mess.

Meanwhile, the Democrats have their heads buried in policy statements trying to devise solutions to problems that may not be solvable in the short run. The rhetoric that councils patience in the face of challenges and promises technical competence will not quell the anger seething in the electorate.

Grayson offers something different—a Democrat who plays the blame game and is unapologetic when he calls out Republicans for their feckless disregard for average Americans. And in using the language of blame he is using explicitly moral language that reminds voters of the moral bankruptcy of conservatism.

Grayson bluntly tells it like it is—our problems resulted from Republican policies and their twisted values. Unless Democrats hammer that home in the strongest possible terms they will lose in 2101.

We need more like Grayson. Obama’s cool competence helped him win the last election, but it may not be sufficient to win the next one.

Resistance to Change

Wednesday, October 28th, 2009

Political philosopher Bill Galston points to disturbing trends in recent political polling.

The current state of American politics presents a paradox. On the one hand, survey after survey testifies to the rock-bottom standing of the Republican Party. Fewer Americans identify with the party than in the past, and fewer trust it to deal with the country’s problems. On the other hand, there are hard-to-ignore signs of a conservative resurgence. A 15,000 person Gallup survey out today shows that 40 percent of Americans now identify themselves as conservative (up from 37 percent at the time of Obama’s election), while only 20 percent regard themselves as liberal (down from 22 percent). Far more independents (35 percent) consider themselves conservative than was the case a year ago (only 29 percent).

These findings would be less compelling if they were not linked to conservative shifts on specific issues–but they are, and the Gallup organization enumerates a considerable list. Among them: increasing opposition to government regulation of business and gun ownership; an uneasy feeling about the influence of labor unions; increasing support for immigration restrictions and government promotion of traditional values; and diminished support for strong action on climate change. The percentage of Americans who believe that government is trying to do too much stands at its highest level (57 percent) in many years. Trust in government is near all-time lows, and Americans believe that 50 cents of every federal tax dollar is wasted–the highest level ever.

When I conceived Reviving the Left, the percentages of self-identified conservatives and liberals were roughly the same as reported in this recent poll.

Despite the historic achievements of liberalism, its recent electoral successes, and the utter collapse of conservatism as a governing philosophy, liberalism still has not captured the political imaginations of most Americans.

In Reviving the Left, I argued that liberalism’s troubles stem from a  variety of false and pernicious background moral beliefs, deeply rooted in the American psyche, that explain the persistence of anti-government attitudes and the mistrust of liberalism. There is as yet no evidence that those background beliefs have changed, despite the extraordinary events that have shaped politics in recent years.

It is likely that only generational change will produce meaningful political change.

Thus, Galston is right to be concerned, although his prescription for less government action is misguided. Without a firmer commitment to liberal principles by a larger proportion of the public, we could very easily slide back into a conservatism that has already shown itself to be nothing but one disaster after another.